Wednesday 7 March 2012

Lee's Honorable Surrender and Newt's Path Forward


Grant’s army cut off Lee’s supply lines, forcing Lee to withdraw from Petersburg. Lee desperately flung his army westward, hoping to reconnect with Lynchburg, with Grant’s army in hot pursuit and attempting a pincer movement. In the final stage, Confederate General Gordon (Georgia) pushed forward only to find the Union 5th Corps entrenched in the heights to his front, and otherwise surrounded by Union elements on three sides of a geological bowl formation. Union artillery was amassed for a fish in the barrel shoot. Knowing when to quit, Lee sent forward a Confederate horserider carrying a white flag.
 
Lee seriously considered scattering his troops to the four winds and persisting in a guerilla war. But Lee thought this was the worst option. In his heart, he wanted to be a positive player in bringing about peace between North and South. He met with Grant. Grant treated him with the dignity he deserved. As General Gordon, dejected in defeat, marched his troops in procession, General Chamberlain formed his 5th Corps and honored his counterpart with a dignatory salute. Thus began the healing of a nation.

We Conservative Republicans, we heirs of the Reagan legacy, have likewise engaged in an epic struggle to put forward our candidate as the one best suited to turn our country around. Newt Gingrich has fought as valiantly as any candidate and is worthy as much honor as any commander. But the way forward for him has come to an end. To persist is self-destructive. It is time for a truce  with Rick Santorum, who holds Gingrich in high respect. It is time to unite this Republican party behind one conservative candidate to defeat the Massachusetts Moderate who will otherwise go the way of McCain and Dole, and would give Obama 4 more destructive years. Together, there is much that can be done, and Gingrich can play a major role therein.

Five Essential Narrative Points for SuperTuesday: A Retrospect and a Prospect


SuperTuesday Narrative:

Santorum (brown) takes most Ohio Counties
The breathtaking sweep of the SuperTuesday elections will undoubtedly yield many stories which will need interpretation. There are, however, five main points in any credible SuperTuesday narrative.

First, Mitt cannot seal the deal. Not even by spending $12 million in two weeks in one state. Not even with the benefit of the Dele-GATE scandal by which he has manipulated either delegate rules or campaign momentum by unscrupulous party misdeeds in Virginia, Ohio, Iowa, Maine, Florida, Arizona, and Michigan. Not even with the support of media giants Fox and Drudge. Not even with the endorsement of major party leaders.

Secondly, Rick is here to stay. Nothing has been easy for Santorum. Yet, he has weathered the blistering unleashed on him by Romney’s campaign treasure chest in every state contest. Romney outspent Santorum 6:1 in Romney’s home turf in Michigan, yet Rick wrestled him to a tie. Again, Romney outspent Santorum 12:1 in Ohio, and again Rick wrestled him to a tie. In both states, Rick did so even though his conservative base was split with Newt, which brings up the third narrative point.

Thirdly, at this point, Mitt’s best friend is Newt who is effectively preventing Rick from competing one-on-one with Mitt, a contest which Rick would clearly win. Newt’s southern strategy is kaput, with key states having been won by Santorum (Missouri, Oklahoma, Tennessee), and polling favorably for Santorum (Mississippi, Alabama, North Carolina).  Santorum has won recent significant straw polls in Texas and is likely to win the important North Shore Tea Party straw poll this weekend in Louisiana. Since there is little more that Newt can accomplish by staying in the race, except to ensure a Romney win, one can only speculate that his continuation is designed to help pad his future conference speaking schedule and book contracts. Newt is quickly in danger of exchanging his reputation as the failed Speaker of the House with the equally onerous title of spoiler for the moderate candidate.

Fourthly, back to Romney and his profligate, Obama-like spending spree. The Romney campaign did not anticipate having to spend so much money at this point in the primary season, and has little left to continue its win-by-smear ad campaign. Fund raising numbers are about to come out for February, and the Romney campaign may be embarrassed to find itself having raised less money than the Santorum campaign. This will have a psychological effect on supporters, especially as they watch Romney resort to writing loan checks from his personal account to his campaign. Apparently, money can NOT buy an election, although it goes very far in keeping someone else from winning.
 
Fifthly, the vastly underfunded, underorganized Santorum campaign demonstrates how much a poorly equipped band of volunteers can do through hard work if they have a capable, relentless candidate with the right ideas. One can hardly avoid an analogy with Gen. Washington and his unprofessional, poorly outfitted army going up against the world’s superpower in the late 1700s. Nothing has been easy for Santorum, and victory is still not in hand. Yet with hardly a moment’s rest, he is off today for a Kansas noon event and to Mississippi for two more events later today in an effort to secure the nomination, just as Gen. Washington pushed on to Princeton after Trenton.

All in all, it was a bad SuperTuesday for Mitt, a great day for Rick, and a devastating day for Newt. It could have been worse or better for either Mitt or Rick. But the draw goes not to the front-runner, but to his opponent.

Monday 5 March 2012

Super Tuesday Run-Down of Candidates


Not Mitt:
  • A johnny-come-lately conservative
  • A conservative of convenience who is likely to resort to his Massachusetts Moderate DNA as soon as he wins the nomination
  • Unreliable for Supreme Court nominations
  • Little or no foreign policy experience or expertise
  • Looks for government to be solution rather than free market
  • Supported the Wall Street bailouts
  • Supported carbon taxes/regulations/global warming
  • Only defeats his competition by spending more money, not by inspiring support
  • Romneycare
  • Cannot beat Obama
    • Does not differ from Obama on Obamacare
    • Will not get support of Tea Party
    • Lacks enthusiastic support
    • Will not carry his own state
    • No electoral map to victory—does not appeal to swing states PA OH MI WI

Not Newt:
  • Newt is no longer a viable candidate.
    • He has lost badly in Iowa, New Hampshire, Florida, Nevada, Missouri, Minnesota, Colorado, Michigan, Arizona, and Washington state.
    • He polls very badly in Oklahoma, Ohio, and Tennessee.
    • He has won only one state.
    • He is now merely dividing the conservative vote, and helping Romney to win.
  • Newt’s tenure as Speaker was a failure.
    • He accomplished much as Speaker (a Republican majority, balanced budgets, Contract with America)
    • In his four years, instead of capitalizing on his Republican majority, he lost seats
    • He imperiled his once huge majority
    • He lost the confidence of his own conservative base
    • He was censured 385-29, an astonishing defeat.
    • Nearly every campaign ad in 1996 and 1998 broadcast against a Republican featured Newt’s face as someone despised by most Americans.
  • Newt has done nothing worthy in the last 10 years to deserve a second chance at leadership.
  • Newt’s conservatism is erratic.
    • Rush Limbaugh has said that Newt debated John Kerry on global warming and agreed with nearly everything Kerry said.
    • Newt promoted the global warming myth in a commercial with Nancy Pelosi.
    • Although he spoke strongly against Al Gore’s global warming data, Newt finished his testimony by saying he would consider some type of cap and trade tax.
  • Newt has been for some kind of health care individual mandate for years.
  • Newt cannot carry the party’s family values label.
  • Newt's primary financial backing is from a casino mogul. When Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics and Liberty Commission's Richard Land raised concerns about a presidential candidate being so beholden to the casino industry, Gingrich doubled-down and accepted another $10 million ($21 million total).
  • Newt cannot beat Obama
    • If Newt is the nominee, Obama will make the election about Newt, capitalizing on Newt’s high negatives
    • Newt has no electoral map to victory; any Republican can carry his home state of Georgia
    • Newt has so much baggage that the national debt could be paid off in his excess baggage fees
    • Obama will not agree to debate Newt

Yes Rick:
  • Limbaugh notes that every single one of the Republican conservatives have compromised significant conservative values, except for Rick Santorum
  • Santorum is the candidate most expert on foreign affairs
  • Santorum is the only candidate to end a major entitlement, authoring and managing his Welfare Reform Act bill into law
  • Santorum’s Made-in America economic plan is “supply side economics for the working man” and will help win America’s “rust-belt states”
  • Santorum is the consistent conservative, who will appoint conservative leaders to his administration
  • Santorum is the most electable